Florida staple, key lime pie!

From a Jersey girl turned Florida native, this sunshine-filled classic has become a Sugar Me Sunshine must-have. Our Key to My Tart features a bright, zesty citrus filling that’s smooth, creamy, and full of Florida flavor, all nestled in a lightly sweet graham cracker crust. Refreshing, indulgent, and perfectly balanced — one bite and you’ll taste why this pie has become a true slice of the Sunshine State.